• Navigation icon for News

    News

    • US Food
    • UK Food
    • Drinks
    • Celebrity
    • Restaurants and bars
    • TV and Film
    • Social Media
  • Navigation icon for Cooking

    Cooking

    • Recipes
    • Air fryer
  • Navigation icon for Health

    Health

    • Diet
    • Vegan
  • Navigation icon for Fast Food

    Fast Food

    • McDonalds
    • Starbucks
    • Burger King
    • Subway
    • Dominos
  • Facebook
    Instagram
    YouTube
    TikTok
    X
  • Advertise
  • Terms
  • Privacy & Cookies
  • LADbible Group
  • LADbible
  • UNILAD
  • SPORTbible
  • GAMINGbible
  • Tyla
  • UNILAD Tech
  • License Our Content
  • About Us & Contact
  • Jobs
  • Latest
  • Archive
  • Topics A-Z
  • Authors
Facebook
Instagram
YouTube
TikTok
X
Submit Your Content
Woman wins $14 million after ice cream left her unable to have kids

Home> News> US Food

Published 13:50 30 Mar 2026 GMT+1

Woman wins $14 million after ice cream left her unable to have kids

The mum initially believed she'd swallowed a nut - only to learn it was metal

Ella Scott

Ella Scott

google discoverFollow us on Google Discover
Featured Image Credit: WESH 2/NBC

Topics: Ice Cream, US Food, News

Ella Scott
Ella Scott

Advert

Advert

Advert

A woman who claimed to have purchased a frozen treat from a Florida institution has been awarded more than $14 million after discovering she could no longer have children as a result of consumption.

In September 2018, Brandy Buckley, 43, said she visited and ate a dessert with her son at Bruster’s Ice Cream in Palm Bay.

According to reports, the ice cream was contaminated with ‘foreign and unnatural objects’, including a nail and ‘metal shards’.

“I noticed there was a metal nail in the cone, almost embedded,” the American mum told WESH-TV. “When I did swallow, I did feel something in my throat that kind of got stuck.”

Advert

Despite initially believing the foreign object was a nut from the butter pecan ice cream cone she purchased at the drive-thru window, Buckley thought that she had actually ‘swallowed a nail’, according to court documents.

An emergency hospital trip and an X-ray confirmed she’d consumed the nail as well as ‘two metal shards’ that had quickly become ‘embedded in her intestines’.

She underwent surgery, later developing a blood clot, which led to complications, including ‘permanent infertility’ that would prevent her ‘from having additional children’.

“An ablation was performed, which ultimately resulted in permanent infertility," her attorneys stated, as per Fox 35.

Buckley, who said it was her ‘goal and dream to have more kids’, claimed she suffered neurological damage and permanent bodily function loss as a result of consumption, the New York Post wrote.

Brandy Buckley was left permenantly infertile after consuming the foreign objects, according to court documents (WESH 2 News)
Brandy Buckley was left permenantly infertile after consuming the foreign objects, according to court documents (WESH 2 News)

The US native also claimed her nervous system was impacted and that she suffered various injuries to her head, limbs, and neck.

In a complaint filed against Bruster’s Ice Cream’s owners, Malabar Creameries, in 2019, the Plaintiff accused them of failing to ensure their frozen products were safe for human consumption.

Buckley’s case went to court, where the six-man Brevard County jury found the national Bruster's franchise and the local ice cream shop liable for damages, Fox 35 wrote.

The jury eventually awarded her $14,147,5245.39 in damages due to the severity of her injuries.

The funds were also awarded to compensate for her hefty medical bills, as reported by LADbible.

The jury awarded the woman more than $14 million after she consumed a nail and metal shards (WESH 2 News)
The jury awarded the woman more than $14 million after she consumed a nail and metal shards (WESH 2 News)

In response to the multi-million dollar settlement, Buckley’s lawyer, John Alpizar, said: “We are grateful that this jury of six fulfilled their civic duty and listened carefully to all of the evidence.

“This verdict reflects the seriousness of the harm our client endured and ensures accountability at all levels.

LADbible Group has previously contacted Bruster’s Ice Cream for comment.

  • Surprising reason why Ben & Jerry's ice cream is always so chunky
  • Popular ice cream urgently recalled over health risks
  • Five Guys CEO Jerry Murrell gives out $1.5 million in bonuses in a bid to make things right
  • McDonald's customer gets very unexpected surprise after ordering ice cream cone

Choose your content:

a day ago
  • Jonathan Wiggs/The Boston Globe via Getty Images
    a day ago

    How 'spice bags' became Ireland's latest cult export

    It's no longer just about splitting the G but scranning Ireland's top late-night dish.

    News
  • SimpleImages/Getty Images
    a day ago

    Garlic recalled at highest level warning over risk of 'serious adverse health consequences or death'

    Anyone who purchased the product can get a refund with a 'valid' receipt

    News
  • Brian van der Brug / Los Angeles Times via Getty Images
    a day ago

    California’s Assembly Bill 2244 will revolutionise how we understand 'health risks' of certain foods

    The proposal includes a game-changing labelling system

    News
  • Channel 4
    a day ago

    Prue Leith's work had to be evacuated after she received 'letter bomb' from disgruntled fan

    The British food icon revealed all in her 2012 memoir

    News