
Protein has become one of the biggest talking points in food and nutrition, with supermarkets filling their shelves with high-protein snacks, yoghurts and even chocolate bars.
Many of us have seen influencers and experts extolling the benefits of 'proteinmaxxing', but surprising new research is bucking the trend.
New reviews suggest that eating more protein is not necessarily better for everyone, and cutting back could have benefits for the way our bodies age.
A major review of more than 350 scientific studies, published in the journal Cell Press Blue, found that reducing protein intake may help improve metabolic health and influence biological processes linked to ageing.
Advert
The researchers also found evidence that protein restriction can extend lifespan in some cases.
The findings challenge the current enthusiasm for high-protein diets, particularly among people who spend much of the day sitting down and lead a fairly sedentary lifestyle.

Corresponding author Dudley Lamming, from the University of Wisconsin-Madison, said: “It's absolutely crystal clear that there are benefits of protein to muscle growth and exercise response of active individuals.”
However, he warned that many people who are relatively sedentary could be eating more protein than they need, potentially with negative consequences for their health.
The review looked at how protein and individual amino acids affect the body's metabolism and its ability to maintain healthy cells.
Amino acids are the building blocks of protein, but they also act as signals, helping regulate processes involved in cell growth and energy use.
Three in particular caught the researchers' attention: methionine, isoleucine and valine.
Consuming too much of these amino acids may activate biological pathways associated with inflammation, obesity and other conditions linked to ageing.
One possible explanation for the effects of a lower-protein diet is a hormone called fibroblast growth factor 21, or FGF21.
Levels of the hormone rise when protein intake is restricted.
It helps regulate how the body uses energy and has been linked to improved blood sugar control and reduced inflammation.
Animal research has found that mice with higher levels of FGF21 can live longer, although the effects appear to differ between males and females.
Whether the same response can extend human lifespan remains unknown.

There have been some encouraging results in human trials, but they have mostly focused on short-term health markers rather than longevity.
A 2022 randomised controlled trial involving 21 people with metabolic syndrome found that a 27-day protein-restricted diet improved insulin sensitivity, blood glucose, blood fats and blood pressure.
The participants did not have to reduce their overall calorie intake to see the changes.
More recently, a five-week study involving 17 men who are overweight or obese found that reducing protein intake from 1.8g to 0.9g per kilogram of body weight per day was associated with an average weight loss of 2kg.
Levels of FGF21 also increased.
But not every human study has found a benefit.
A 2026 randomised crossover trial gave 63 healthy adults either an average-protein diet or a reduced-protein diet for four weeks each.
Researchers found that cutting protein did not increase autophagy, which is the process through which cells break down and recycle damaged components.
There were also no meaningful differences in fasting glucose, insulin, cholesterol or blood pressure, either.

That is an important reminder that promising results in animals do not always translate into the same effects in people.
Protein remains essential for building and repairing muscle, maintaining tissues and supporting recovery after exercise.
Older adults may need to pay particular attention to getting enough, as muscle loss can affect mobility and increase the risk of falls.
Pregnant women and people who exercise regularly also have different nutritional requirements.
Lamming believes recommendations should take account of activity levels as well as age. “We probably need to personalize protein recommendations based not just on age, but also on how physically active people are,” he said.
It also comes as nutrition experts are encouraging people to think beyond protein.
NHS GP Dr Rupy Aujla has also urged people to focus on fibre for better gut health, highlighting the importance of legumes, fruit, vegetables, nuts and seeds.
For now, this new research has raised questions about whether the current push to add extra protein to almost everything is necessary, particularly for people who are not especially active.



