• Navigation icon for News

    News

    • US Food
    • UK Food
    • Drinks
    • Celebrity
    • Restaurants and bars
    • TV and Film
    • Social Media
  • Navigation icon for Cooking

    Cooking

    • Recipes
    • Air fryer
  • Navigation icon for Health

    Health

    • Diet
    • Vegan
  • Navigation icon for Fast Food

    Fast Food

    • McDonalds
    • Starbucks
    • Burger King
    • Subway
    • Dominos
  • Facebook
    Instagram
    YouTube
    TikTok
    X
  • Advertise
  • Terms
  • Privacy & Cookies
  • LADbible Group
  • LADbible
  • UNILAD
  • SPORTbible
  • GAMINGbible
  • Tyla
  • UNILAD Tech
  • License Our Content
  • About Us & Contact
  • Jobs
  • Latest
  • Archive
  • Topics A-Z
  • Authors
Facebook
Instagram
YouTube
TikTok
X
Submit Your Content
Why you should always order your In-N-Out burger 'mustard-grilled'

Home> Fast food

Published 16:35 16 Mar 2026 GMT

Why you should always order your In-N-Out burger 'mustard-grilled'

Hilary Duff shared the tip on Table Manners... IYKYK

Britt Jones

Britt Jones

google discoverFollow us on Google Discover
Featured Image Credit: Jay L. Clendenin/Getty Images

Topics: Fast Food, US Food, Celebrity

Britt Jones
Britt Jones

Advert

Advert

Advert

In-n-Out has a number of famous faces among its fans, including Sinners star Michael B. Jordan, who decided to celebrate his recent Oscars win by taking his golden statuette out for a burger - as you do.

Hilary Duff is also not shy about her love for the American fast food chain, having grown particularly fond of a special menu tweak that you may not even know about.

It's on In-N-Out's 'Not So Secret Menu' selection - advertised quite openly on its website - so it's more IYKYK than a truly guarded mystery.

But what it lacks in secrecy it more than makes up for in flavour, being a simple change that makes ALL the difference.

Advert

Hilary Duff explained how she likes her burgers cooked (Photo by Emma McIntyre/Getty Images for ABA)
Hilary Duff explained how she likes her burgers cooked (Photo by Emma McIntyre/Getty Images for ABA)

So, how can you order it?

If you go on the brand’s site, you can choose six menu alterations, including a 4x4 burger with four beef patties, the 3x3 triple burger, the protein bun-free burger, a double meat, grilled cheese, or ‘Animal Style’ option.

Now, it’s the Animal Style that has everyone talking about, and that’s thanks to pop singer, Duff.

Speaking on the latest episode of Table Manners with Jessie and Lennie Ware, the songstress revealed why she always orders her beef burgers 'mustard grilled' and what it means.

Duff, 38, was asked what her ‘last supper’ would be, comprising of a breakfast, lunch, dinner, and dessert.

To this, she said if she were to eat her last supper, it would include her mustard grilled patty.

After asking if her menu picks would ‘have to go together’ and wondered if the hosts would be ‘disgusted’ with her random choices, she revealed her last meal would be an In-N-Out burger, as she asked: “How do you get better than an In-N-Out burger?”

Eat your burger Mustard Grilled (Photo by Emma McIntyre/Getty Images for ABA)
Eat your burger Mustard Grilled (Photo by Emma McIntyre/Getty Images for ABA)

The singer then said: “Have you ever asked for it mustard fried? They put mustard on the burger and then they fry it, and it just adds this depth.”

After salivating over her description, I headed to the burger company’s website to find out more about the mustard process, to find out that a mustard grilled/fried burger comes with caramelised chopped onions, an extra stack of pickle slices, tomato, and patties that are fried with mustard on the griddle.

Food blog writer and recipe recreator Serious Eats once tried to recreate the In-n-Out Animal Style mustard grilled burger, using frozen and shipped burgers for reference as the chain wasn’t local enough to visit.

They said: “The process is simple: Sear the patty on one side, and squirt some mustard on it as it sizzles. Flip the patty over so that the mustard cooks into the second side.

“The patties are covered with cheese, then caramelized onions are applied liberally to a single patty before topping it with the second, fusing all the elements together into a single cheesy, beefy, sweet, oniony, gooey, salty, oozy, crispy, meaty, savory, melty, delicious mess."

Oh, yes.

Choose your content:

9 hours ago
12 hours ago
14 hours ago
a day ago
  • Catherine Falls Commercial/Getty Images
    9 hours ago

    Heart surgeon issues warning over 'liquid death' drink people have every day

    One heart specialist has issued a stern warning about a drink he says is 'liquid death', and you might be surprised by what it is

    Fast food
  •  Matt Cardy/Getty Images
    12 hours ago

    New voice of McDonald's is cult British star you'll definitely recognise

    A famous voice is taking over the McDonald's brand and will be appearing in adverts soon

    Fast food
  • Starbucks
    14 hours ago

    Starbucks' new Cloud Frappuccino range kicks off summer early with huge menu shakeup

    Introducing the unique Cloud Frappuccino and its sweet and savoury friends

    Fast food
  • McDonald's
    a day ago

    McDonald's launches new line of sodas and refreshers

    The six exciting beverages launch after a year in the making

    Fast food
  • In-N-Out Burger sues YouTuber following controversial stunt
  • Mary J Blige says she lost friends over controversial Burger King ad
  • Burger King launches new Star Wars menu
  • Domino's worker reveals why you should never order by phone