• Navigation icon for News

    News

    • US Food
    • UK Food
    • Drinks
    • Celebrity
    • Restaurants and bars
    • TV and Film
    • Social Media
  • Navigation icon for Cooking

    Cooking

    • Recipes
    • Air fryer
  • Navigation icon for Health

    Health

    • Diet
    • Vegan
  • Navigation icon for Fast Food

    Fast Food

    • McDonalds
    • Starbucks
    • Burger King
    • Subway
    • Dominos
  • Facebook
    Instagram
    YouTube
    TikTok
    X
  • Advertise
  • Terms
  • Privacy & Cookies
  • LADbible Group
  • LADbible
  • UNILAD
  • SPORTbible
  • GAMINGbible
  • Tyla
  • UNILAD Tech
  • License Our Content
  • About Us & Contact
  • Jobs
  • Latest
  • Topics A-Z
  • Authors
Facebook
Instagram
YouTube
TikTok
X
Submit Your Content
Warning over eating pumpkin flesh after carving it

Home> Cooking> Recipes

Published 08:39 14 Oct 2025 GMT+1

Warning over eating pumpkin flesh after carving it

Pumpkins are delicious and look amazing when carved, but be careful of eating them after carving

Kit Roberts

Kit Roberts

It's October, and anyone who loves this time of year knows exactly what means.

Yes, it is once again spooky season, our modern iteration of Samhain (pronounced sow-wayn) where the veil between the worlds of the living and the dead is at its thinnest: Halloween.

That means it's time to grab the largest pumpkin you can find and carve a spooky design into the front of it.

Jack-o-Lanterns are believed to have originated as a Samhain practice in Ireland and Scotland, where people would carve designs into turnips or mangelwurzels (yes, that's a real vegetable) as a way to ward off evil spirits.

Advert

The name Jack-o-Lantern originates as the mysterious lights which would appear over peat bogs at night, similar to Will-o-the-wisps, which you must never follow.

While carving a pumpkin is a fun tradition at Halloween, cooking the pumpkin after carving it may see you visited by something other than evil spirits.

Can you carve a pumpkin and eat it later?

They do look very cool (Creative Touch Imaging Ltd./NurPhoto via Getty Images)
They do look very cool (Creative Touch Imaging Ltd./NurPhoto via Getty Images)

It's a sensible enough question given that you can eat pumpkins right away. That all changes when you've carved into it, though.

The answer is bacteria. A pumpkin's skin acts as a protective barrier, but if you cut through that to carve it you expose the nutritious flesh inside to all sorts of bugs that can then start to grow there.

A cut pumpkin should be refrigerated, but putting a candle inside a Jack-o-Lantern - as is common practice - obviously has quite the opposite effect.

Jonathan Deutsch, a food and hospitality management professor at Drexel University in Philadelphia, told the Huffington Post: “Keep in mind that vegetables, including pumpkins, once cut, are considered a TCS - time and temperature controlled for safety - food.

“That means that it should be cooked immediately or kept refrigerated and cooked within a couple of days for optimal food safety.”

How can you decorate a pumpkin and still eat it?

Carving pumpkins are not good for eating (Creative Touch Imaging Ltd./NurPhoto via Getty Images)
Carving pumpkins are not good for eating (Creative Touch Imaging Ltd./NurPhoto via Getty Images)

You can still put designs onto a pumpkin and eat it, as long as you don't break the skin in doing so.

This might include using stickers on the outside.

Alternatively, you could mix up some edible paint from sugar, cornstarch, water, and food colouring and decorate that way.

You won't get that classic spooky glow this way, but you will cut down on food waste.

Are carving pumpkins good for eating?

Some pumpkins are grown for eating (Creative Touch Imaging Ltd./NurPhoto via Getty Images)
Some pumpkins are grown for eating (Creative Touch Imaging Ltd./NurPhoto via Getty Images)

The short answer is yes - and no.

Carving pumpkins are different from the ones which are grown for food, as well as the types of squashes you might have.

While the eating ones are a lot sweeter and more tender, carving pumpkins can be tougher, stringier, and blander, meaning you may have to work a bit harder with your recipe - adding more spices, seasonings and such.

You could also save the seeds that you scoop out, as these can be toasted off and mixed with salt and whatever flavourings you like for a tasty snack.

If you have one, there is always the compost heap as well.

Featured Image Credit: Olga Rolenko/Getty Images

Topics: News, Recipes, Health

Kit Roberts
Kit Roberts

Advert

Advert

Advert

Choose your content:

a month ago
  • Instagram/@brooklynpeltzbeckham
    a month ago

    Fans have same complaint about Brooklyn Beckham's chicken recipe

    The son of David and Victoria Beckham has said he tries to 'put his head down' when it comes to social media criticism

    Cooking
  • SGAPhoto/Getty Images
    a month ago

    Grim reason you should never cook pigs in blankets in air fryer

    A warning for anyone planning on cooking up a storm this Christmas

    Cooking
  • Bloomberg/Getty Images
    a month ago

    Brits are absolutely roasting American's attempt at fry up breakfast

    Brits deliver a hilarious, brutal roasting of an American's breakfast attempt

    Cooking
  • Anastasiia Sienotova/Getty Images
    a month ago

    Christmas cookie cutter leaves people absolutely stumped

    Other Redditors were left baffled over the cookie cutter shape

    Cooking
  • Warning to anyone who eats spinach after it tops very undesirable list
  • Experts share warning over cooking popular breakfast item in air fryer
  • Warning over drinking water on planes following major new study
  • Warning over TikTok wooden spoon hack and what you should do instead